So I spent some time looking at the differences in video recording and displaying on both the DroidX and the iPhone4. So here are some thoughts…I going to break them down according to the device. I explain a little more in the iPhone4 description, but this is where I define some terms for the rest of the write-up.
iPhone4 Thoughts
1) The video quality is great especially since it is acquiring the image at 720p – 30 frames/second. This means that the video image is 720 lines across the width of the video display. It uses a progressive scan where the image is displayed line but line from top to bottom across the page. There is a debate whether progressive or interlaced is beter, but a progressive scan provides less visual artifacts and less motion blurring. Here is an article about progressive (the “p” in 720p) and interlacing (the “i” in the 720i). I think that the actual resolution of the iPhone4 is a little better than the DroidX camera, with less visual artifacts, but does not have the chroma in outdoor settings as the DroidX.
2) The back camera focal length is 3.85 mm with f-stop of 2.8. This is essentially equal in focal length with a 35mm SLR camera with a 30mm lens. This is a pretty wide angle lens with a wide range of view. It is a pretty good camera, but for people like me…I want the original file. If you email the file or upload it to FTP site/YouTube, it compresses the video. So, I have to dock the phone to retrieve video in the most native format. Great articles by Ars Technica and Falk Lumo about the camera.
3) When recording the video from the camera, you are not allowed to zoom. You have to use your body to zoom by walking closer to the subject.
4) Displaying on an monitor, you have to purchase the PC adapter for the iPad. This allows you connect to a monitor that has a PC (VGA) input. This will not allow you to play the sound on the monitor, you have to connect the earphone out to the monitor or speakers using a mini-plug. The PC (VGA) connector is $29 on the Apple.com website. But you will also need a PC (VGA) cable to complete the connection.
5) Controlling what is displayed on the external monitor is tricky. It only will display pictures/video from camera or video form the YouTube application. Displaying videos from the camera can be tricky. Sometimes if you select to play the video, it might not immediately display on the external monitor. The same with pictures, you have to be in a slideshow mode to get the monitor to recognize the images.
6) It has two cameras! This is cool, one on the front and one on the back. This allows the user to record videos or take pictures using either camera. The front camera also allows the ability to do face-to-face video phone calls. You can just touch the screen to select which camera to use to record. I have actually used the front camera to record a video and it gives me a frame of reference for what I am recording. It allows to frame yourself properly without lots of mysterious room above your head. The back camera is the one with the flash for taking photos in low light.
DroidX Thoughts
1) The video quality is great with the ability to record in 720p. It has great image quality but when displaying the video on a Flat Screen HDTV, I noticed some artifacts in high contrast areas. Basically, when you watch the video on the HDTV and walk up close to the screen, you will see block like images around high-contrast areas. But, the DroidX had better chroma quality than the iPhone4…the video did not look as washed out.
2) The focal length of the DroidX’s camera is a little wider than the iPhone4, giving the ability to capture more landscape. I had to back up some with the iPhone to capture the same image as the DroidX. Also, since I am a Mac user, I can connect the DroidX via the USB cable and navigate to find the video files. This allows me to download the native video files to edit.
3) You can zoom with the video camera on the DroidX, very cool.
4) Displaying on a monitor is done with an HDMI mini-D to HDMI cable. This can be purchased for $39.99 at a Verizon Retail store or $24.99 online at Verizon.com. Yeah…$15.00 extra bucks to purchase in the store! Not Good!
5) Controlling what is displayed on the external monitor is a little tricky but a great idea. Once you connect the DroidX via the HDMI cable to the external monitor; you can select a picture or video and the media plays on the external monitor screen. Then the DroidX turns into a remote control. Great idea and neat interface.
OK…after many requests…here are my initial thoughts of the DroidX! I do have to give a shout out to Robin Blackwood at JDPR for letting me play with this toy!
Well…watch the video first of all. This video covers the apps I use, the Mobile Hot Spot feature and a few other details.
One of the big questions from a lot of developers is whether the DroidX can be rooted. Basically to get to the core of the code. If this is your cup of tea…here is the link to the Engadget Post –> CLICK HERE or watch the video below!
I have a new video coming comparing the video playback of the DroidX and the iPhone4. Good stuff and I am using the cameras from the phones to show the difference in the video quality.
One of my close friends (Brian Lindenmeyer) recently purchased the DroidX and has been working on a document with his review of the phone (Below). I think he has some great thoughts and even slams my beloved Apple iPhone4, but I like his points overall.
Awaiting the update to fix some Wi-Fi signal issues, corporate sync issues, and battery meter issues. Overall, this device is more than I could have ever imagined. Lots of this love for the Droid is based on the simple, but robust, integration to Google services. We’ll cover this under applications.
UPDATE 7/20/2010 (9am) – I got the update from Verizon – so far things are definitely improved.
Couple other things: I think the built-in launcher is fine, but did like Launcher Pro (may try it again). I also didn’t find that any enhancement to the SMS messaging was needed. Lastly, I do set up Twitter and Facebook as I like the contact integration, but the Twitter app that is built-in only supports one account, so grab another one if you have two…I’m still looking.
Platform/ROM/Built-in Apps
Not that I need to given the RAM, but I am looking forward to ROOTING this device to removes some bloatware (Amazon MP3, Blockbuster, CityID, etc.). Otherwise, the first thing any Blackberry converts like myself need to realize is:
1. Android manages memory much better
2. Instead of folders to remove or arrange icons on the main screen, you have desktops to do this. Your “cabinet” or folder of applications is more like an iPhone.
Aside from the bloat (and l lack of rooting/custom ROMs – we’ll skip that at the moment) – this phone simply rocks. If you aren’t a Google Fan, you better be if you use this. The integration to Google services is without a doubt the best integration of any device – and I’m including the MobileMe Apple garbage. REMEMBER – Apple charges for that – Google doesn’t.
Must have – The Google Additions:
I’ll start with the Google Apps (or tightly integrated to Google services):
Google Voice: If you don’t have a google voice number – get one. The ability to use this phone as a secondary number is fantastic, along with the ability to call international at low rates. But what is the best part is free visual/transcribed voicemails. Yes, you can even text from your Google Voice number (although I’ve never done this, since I only text my friends who have my cell phone number – no need to confuse the less-technically savvy. Fantastic launcher replacement with tons of options to tweak and lots of great features. I still like LauncherPro Beta better (see below), but this one is a very close 2nd.
GTasks: This app/widget allows you to enter tasks into your Google Task list and syncs with the server. This task list is integrated into the Google calendar online. Only issue is that Google Tasks doesn’t support reoccurring tasks, so for that I suggest you make reoccurring events on your google calendar.
Google Listen: I thought the worse thing leaving my Blackberry behind would be losing PodTrapper – which I used to automatically get podcasts delivered to my device OTA so I could listen on planes or when driving. Enter Google Listen. This app is integrated to Google Reader (the RSS application Google has) and allows you to subscribe to RSS podcast feeds. The only issue is that it doesn’t queue the podcasts automatically, but I have found that it downloads them quickly and allows for offline listening. PERFECT.
Google Maps/Navigation: Built-in, better grab the update that’s available from what was loaded just to be sure. By the way, I gave my wife my Garmin Nuvi…this GPS is better. Only issue is that the ETA is a bit off, even after calibration. I guess Google is trying to be green and tell me to slow down.
Google Shopper: Simple app that allows image, voice, or type searches on products to give you local and web pricing on the item. This is just like going to shopper.google.com, only it’s built for the phone and has the voice and image search. I took a picture of a RedBull Sugar Free…and instantly found the lowest price locally near me (KMart) and of course some online vendors
Google Talk (GTalk): Since I lost BBM (Blackberry Messenger), I’ve had to get back on GTalk. Well, the beauty I forgot about is that GTalk can save chat history in your GMail so that you can search for it later. Great when sharing links with friends, etc. or you just want to refer back to the thread. Use “is:chat” in the GMail search…and yes, you can also do this from the GMail phone app!
SMS Backup: OKAY – I know this isn’t a GOOGLE app, but folks, this may be the best FREE app there is. Simple and does what the title says – backs up your text messages to your gmail account. This is a must have since this makes it easy to search texts (They get automatically labeled as SMS). SIMPLY AWESOME. I will pay for this app if/when needed.
Market Apps I use:
Quick Settings: Quick access to all the essential settings (ringer, brightness, wifi, bluetooth, etc.) with an easy to use UI. You can select from many different settings to display on the main dialog, and can even add a shortcut to it in your notification bar.
Pandora: Great app as usual
Slacker Radio: I have this in addition to Pandora as I don’t have a ton of custom channels on Pandora – and if I want to just listen to 80’s, Slacker has all the channels pre-configured. While Pandora is my bread-n-butter, this is a close 2nd in terms of streaming radio/media.
Amazon App: Look, I’m a prime member, and I basically order everything from Amazon. Great app, just as good as it was on the Blackberry, only now I have a huge screen to look at the stuff!
Kindle App: Again, I had this on the Blackberry, but now I have a much better screen. Who needs a Kindle when you have a Droid X that can read just fine!
ShopSavvy: Great for comparing prices by scanning UPC codes. It will search online as well as nearby stores (if you let it use GPS). This also is a built-in QR Code reader as well. Worth keeping just for that.
TempMonitor: Keep an eye on your battery or cpu temps by sticking it in the notification bar. Since I have the cardock, the device can get hot running GPS up near the window. Good to monitor this.
Facebook for Android: Syncs pictures (not flawless, but works), and is a decent app. The widget is the main thing, but the fact is that I use the web / touch web interface. I do use the social network app/ widget built-in that gives you a feed of twitter and facebook in on view.
Twitter for Android: Yes, this is on my device because all other apps over this past weekend (7/18-7/19) didn’t work due to API issues. I will go to Touiteur or Tweetcaster. I like Tweetcaster since it is Free and supports 2 accounts (it does have ads on the bottom). But I may drop the money on Touiteur since my buddy on a Droid swears by it.
Adobe Reader: While OpenOffice is built-in for viewing, I like the Adobe Reader app as it has more functionality and I get a ton of pdf attachments via email. Enough said.
HomePipe: Access files on your home PC directly from your phone. You can also stream your mp3s to the built-in media player. Great app for basically connecting all PC’s you have that are on and running the PC-based app. Not completely cloud, but still cool
QuickDesk Beta: Lets you access your most used programs from anywhere, without having to minimize anything you’re working on.
SyncMyPix: This app actually stores the Facebook photos in your Google Contacts, whereas Facebook for Android only matches the photos up so they display in your Contacts on your phone. If you don’t want people’s Facebook profile pics stored in your Google Contacts, don’t use this.
Bubble: Simple bubble app and leveler. While the bottom of the device isn’t completely flat, still cool in case the wife asks you to hang some pictures! Works on all sides.
DirecTV Scheduler: Great app for those with DirecTV and DVR’s. Search, browse, and schedule recordings from your phone for any of your DVR’s. Supports single or season recording. Was using it when it came out for Blackberry, glad to see it’s here on Android.
FitDeck Mobile (Bodyweight): I travel and this is a great app for bodyweight exercises I can do in the hotel room. The also have a Pilates, Office, and Stairs program. I own Pilates, and will be buying the other two soon.
iHeartRadio: Yes, in case Pandora and Slacker aren’t getting it done, I can switch to iHeartRadio (Clear Channel). Not great, but still worth checking out.
NotePad: Since Google Docs, and the integration in general, doesn’t have a replacement for Outlook notes, I use this. Doesn’t sync, but still a nice app. If need be, I just create a task (with no reminder) on GTasks, or I go to Google Docs via the browser.
ScoreMobile: Great score app (alternatively I’m trying out SportsTap as well…both are equal, but I like ScoreMobile since I’m used to it from Blackberry days)
USAToday: I read it when in the hotels, now I get it on my device. The news feed widgets are preconfigured for USA Today feeds so this may be a bit redundant.
Other Apps recommended (but I haven’t tried), compliments of Rbb Christie (@ronx):
TripIt: If you use TripIt online, this is a must-have. Gives you quick access to your travel itineraries in an easy-to-read format. The TripIt service is pretty cool. You can email confirmations you receive from airlines/travel services/hotels to the tripit email address and it will automatically add all the info to your account.
IMDb: App for looking up movies, showtimes, trailers, etc. I use the website all the time on my PC, so this should come in handy. Just recently released, so I haven’t had many chances to use it yet. Good chance this will move into my must have list once I start using it.
OK…so here it is! Watch the two videos below. I want to thank Robin Blackwood at JDPR and Verizon for giving me an opportunity today to sit and play with the new DroidX. First of all it is cool. The first video shows me just playing with the DroidX for the first time.
The second video shows this cool feature called “Swype” where you can drag your finger across the keyboard to spell different words.
More to come and I might have one in my hands to play with for an extended amount of time? Maybe even next week!
In the video, I basically look over some of the functions that I have been testing, but after taking on this project…I have had so much interaction about this craze over Android, Droid, DroidX, and on, and on, and on. I have more friends, fraternity brothers, and some random people calling for my opinions and thoughts. Some have even offered me money for the HTC Incredible…we know that is not going to happen. But, I have found a new community of advocates for a totally different platform other than my iPhone status-quo.
But here is my question…or thought, I am still trying to sift my way through all this branding mess. So when I was in Best Buy the other day, I asked the dude to explain a couple of things to me. How is Android different from Droid and DroidX? Two very similar branding conventions that have some things in common but totally separate brand. I have honestly been walking around this whole time, after seeing all the Droid commercials, thinking that Droid was just a shortened version (from a naming convention) of Android. I just began to realize that Android is the platform, Droid is a phone, and DroidX is the newer version of of the Droid. This is freaking confusing for someone who is the target market for Verizon…to entice to make the switch. I have to admit that Apple makes all this branding so freaking simple. I even learned that Motorola had to pay a butt load of money to Lucas Films to use the word “Droid.” That is a lot of money and I still had to get out a pen and paper to connect the dots for the Ah Ha moment.
OK, now that I have tackled that little conundrum. I do not care if people think I am an air-head, but Verizon and Motorola need to sit back and think through some of this branding…Android, Droid, DroidX…RoboCop please. I really do like my friends at Verizon and have enjoyed playing with the Incredible, I even want to buy one and sign-up for a package. Enough on the branding…that is a problem for the big daddy marketing company that has the big daddy contract.
Now on to the what else I found in Best Buy…a demo model of the DroidX. It is a non-functioning demo, but it gave me a chance to hold it and compare it side-by-side with the HTC Incredible and the iPhone4. The DroidX is bigger…well I think a lot bigger. Bigger screen size, bigger camera, bigger battery, bigger in width and height, and has a ridge in the back that props it up somewhat.
I just wonder what it is like to put it in your pocket and use it on a daily basis. I have also heard that Motorola might either lock down the “Root” or even encrypt the “Root” making it a lot harder for “hackers” to boost the performance and alter the settings. I even had one of my buddies tell me if he finds out the “Root” is encrypted then he will forgo the DroidX and just get the HTC Incredible.
My fraternity brother called me tonight and had a long conversation about the DroidX and he spent about an hour telling why the DroidX is going to ROCK. He then went on to remind me that since I am a video guy that the DroidX is going to not only be able to shoot HD Quality video but also immediately replay it with the HDMI out. That would be kind-of cool in a client meeting! Here is a link he sent me comparing the DroidX and the HTC Incredible.
This allows you connect to a monitor that has a PC (VGA) input. This will not allow you to play the sound on the monitor, you have to connect the earphone out to the monitor or speakers using a mini-plug. The PC (VGA) connector is $29 on the Apple.com website. But you will also need a PC (VGA) cable to complete the connection.
This can be purchased for $39.99 at a Verizon Retail store or $24.99 online at Verizon.com. Yeah…$15.00 extra bucks to purchase in the store! Not Good!
